Concurrent Causation in Insurance – A Comparative Study Between England and France
Abstract
This paper aims to define and outline the legal framework governing whether insurers’ liability, and therefore insurance coverage, remains valid in the presence of concurrent causations. It uses a comparative qualitative methodology, with an analysis of case law, statute, and academic literature to attempt to understand where responsibility lies and whether the apparent simplicity of the French Civil law contains useful legislation that could be applied to future reforms for English and Welsh law. The paper aims to find that the law in England and Wales lacks clarity and strong precedent. There is an overlap between insurance law and liability, and the complexity with respect to concurrent causation affects the validity of many insurance claims. This causes legal difficulties where insurance claims cannot easily be concluded. The paper recommends reform to the law of England and Wales to adopt a legal principle similar to French civil law, where damage is fully compensated, regardless of cause, removing the complexity of concurrent causation entirely, providing better consumer support, and reducing a drain on court resources by speeding up processes.
Metrics
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##
Concurrent causationInsurance liabilityCivil liabilityInsurance lawProximate cause
Abraham K.S. Environmental Liability and the Limits of Insurance, (1988) 88 Colum L Rev 942. https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1349&context=faculty_scholarship.
Ansell R., Handley K. ‘A Significant Development In Covid-19 BI Insurance Litigation – Concurrent Causation Applies To “At The Premises” Wordings: London International Exhibition Centre Plc V Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Plc & Ors’ (4 Pump Court website 21 June 2023)
Baker T., Siegelman P., (2013) ‘The Law and Economics of Liability Insurance: A Theoretical and Empirical Review’ (All Faculty Scholarship, Pen Carey Law 2013) 350
Brewer Jr, W ‘Concurrent Causation in Insurance Contracts’, (1961) 59 (8) Mich L Rev. 1141.
Clarke, M. ‘Law of Insurance Contracts’ (loose-leaf, Informa 2021 release), [25-6B].
Clyde & Co ‘Concurrent Proximate Cause’ (Website, 17 July 2018)
Fletcher A., Kramer A. ‘Insurance Contract Law: Causation’ (Thomson Reuters Practical Law Online, 2023)
Gat A., Concurrent Causation: Explained by a Public Adjuster’ (website, 2023)
Harrington, J. ‘Concurrent Causation: An Adjuster’s Dilemma’, (Adjusters International 2020)
Houser D G, Kent C H (1986). ‘Concurrent Causation In First-Party Insurance Claims; Consumers Cannot Afford Concurrent Causation’ Tort & Insurance Law Journal, 21(4), 573–589 www.jstor.org/stable/25761723 > accessed 12th March 2024.
Howard C. ‘‘Insurance Act 2015: Good News or Bad?’ (Mills and Reeve, 10 December 2016)
Lindsay R. and Urquart S., ‘Concurrent Causation and Insurance Contracts’ (2016)
Mei T S, ‘Insurance in between: A critique of liability insurance and its principles’, (2007) 21(1) Literature and Theology 82.
Merkin, Robert and Gürses, Özlem ‘Insurance Contracts after the Insurance Act 2015’ (2016) 132 (3) Law Quarterly Review, 445
Meydan N., Reversac J M, (2023) ‘Legal Update for Insurance Sector in France’ (Clyde & Co website, 11 April 2023)
Moréteau, Olivier. ‘Causal Uncertainty and Proportional Liability in France’ in Proportional Liability: Analytical and Comparative Perspectives, (Eds) Israel Gilead, Michael D. Green and Bernhard A. Koch, (De Gruyter, Boston 2013) 141-152
–––. ‘France: French Tort Law in the Light of European Harmonization’, (2013) 6 (2) J Civ L Stud 15
Poisson E and Metois J, ‘Insurance Disputes: France’ (Allen & Overy website 23 October 2023)
Richards K ‘Causing dissent: Professor Malcom Clarke and Sufficient Concurrent Causation’ University of Bristol (BILA, Platinum Edition Journal, 2022)
Samothrakis Y and Gremaud S, ‘Insurance & Reinsurance Laws and Regulations France 2023’ (ICLG Website, 2023)
Steward D ‘A Peril Insured’: Proximate Cause and the Case of Miss Jay Jay’ (2018)
Zhao L. ‘Insurer’s Liability Under Concurrent Causation: English Law and Chinese Law Compared’ (2021) 42 (1) Legal Studies 120 < DOI:10.1017/lst.2021.31> accessed 15th March 2024.
II. Caselaw:
Anderson v Minneapolis (1920) 146 Minn. 430, 179 NW 45.
Atlasnavios-Navegação, LDA (formerly Bnavios-Navegação, LDA) v Navigators Insurance Co Ltd and others (The B Atlantic) [2019] AC 136.
Baker v Willoughby [1970] AC 46.
Civ. 2e., 15 June 2023, n° 21-20.538.
Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562.
Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services [2003] 1 AC 32.
Financial Conduct Authority v Arch Insurance (UK) Ltd [2021] UKSC 1 para 174.
JJ Lloyd Instruments v Northern Star Insurance Co (The Miss Jay Jay) [1987] 1 Lloyd’s Rep. 32.
New Zealand Fire Service Commission v Legg [2016] NZHC 1492.
Paris Court of Appeal, 21 June 2022 (n°20/10832).
Spire Healthcare Ltd v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Ltd [2022] EWCA Civ 17.
Wayne Tank and Pump Co. Ltd. v Employers Liability Assurance Corporation Ltd. [1974] Q.B. 57.
III. Statute:
Compensation Act 2006.